Biden Strengthens Clean Water Rules
The new regulations repeal a Trump-era rule, called the “Dirty Water Rule” by many, that left millions of acres of waterways unprotected from pollution and that federal courts had invalidated. The Clean Water Act helps protect our nation’s valuable wetlands, streams, and other waterbodies from reckless development and pollution by requiring people and businesses to get a permit before discharging pollutants into waters of the United States.
PEER fought vigorously against the Trump rule. We sued with partner organizations to stop the rule from taking effect, and we filed a Scientific Integrity Act complaint on behalf of current and former experts from the Environmental Protection Agency, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. The complaint documented how Trump-era political appointees excluded key scientific information and its experts in developing the Dirty Water Rule.
While not perfect, the Biden rule is a significant victory for those working to restore protections to the nation’s waterways, particularly wetlands, ponds, streams and arroyos, and other intermittent waterbodies that are not immediately adjacent to traditionally navigable waters. The rule reinstates protections for many important waterbodies that both Democratic and Republic administrations and the courts had protected for decades.
The benefits will be felt throughout the country, including in and around our public lands. For example, according to the National Parks Conservation Association, restored protections in our parks may include:
- Restored protections for an estimated 86% of Indiana Dunes National Park’s wetlands. The park is one of the most biodiverse in the country and is home to the Great Marsh and more than 1500 plant and animal species.
- Restored protections for an estimated 81% of the wetlands in the Big Cypress Swamp watershed. This includes sections of Everglades National Park. The park is home to many endangered and threatened species including the Florida panther and supports roughly $110 million in visitor spending and more than 1500 local jobs.
- Stronger protections for wetlands in and around the Great Smoky Mountains. Wetlands are critical for improving the health of park waterways, better protecting its prized native book trout and the area’s recreational fishing industry.
Because the Biden rule creates new legal standards under the Clean Water Act, we can expect additional litigation from the industries and developers opposed to these changes. In addition, groups like PEER will have to continue to closely monitor how this new rule is applied and enforced and to keep our eyes on the outcome of a case before the Supreme Court that could gut the Clean Water Act.
That case, called Sackett v EPA, also examines which waters are protected by the Clean Water Act and may fundamentally change the legal foundation of the Biden clean water rule.
Tim Whitehouse is the Executive Director of PEER. Among other things, Tim formerly served as an EPA enforcement attorney.